The Role of Professional Critics in the Performing Arts
People give theater critics a bad name. More often than not, they think of a theater critic as a person who says just negative things. “[There’s] a stereotype of the place, it’s opening night, and then everyone has kind of raced to the bar essentially, and they’ve looked at the newspaper. And the newspaper says ‘Oh, this play is terrible,'” states Dr. Harvey Young, an online performing arts education professional. “And that’s not actually the job of a theater critic.”
The job of a theater critic is actually to be an honest, objective, and reliable performing arts education source for a larger public. Their purpose is to acknowledge that not all of their readers will ever go see the play, but that they still want to be informed. They want to know more about what is happening.
The critic will tell readers, honestly, what they think of the production and be objective. They are not related to anyone who made the play. They are not an actor in the production. They will just tell you whether or not it is worthwhile for you to spend your hard-earned money and two to three hours of your time to attend the event and to see the show.
The performing arts critic is not going to be negative. They’ll just be honest. That is the job of a theater critic: to connect with the reader and share their opinion. The thing about theater critics is that those critics who are truly negative never last long. You’ll notice that likable theater critics become the most passionate and ardent advocates for certain productions. “[If] you look at the theater criticism around “In the Heights,” which was Lin-Manuel Miranda’s play before “Hamilton,” that play was nurtured, it was supported, it was sort of praised again and again by theater critics going, ‘Hey, you’ve got to go see this thing,'” Dr. Young says.
The same thing happened with the work of Tennessee Williams. People had no idea who Tennessee Williams was. It was early theater critics who said, “There’s something happening down the street. You’ve got to go check this out.” When “A Raisin in the Sun” first came out, there was a buzz created by critics. It was critics who saw the play in New Haven, Chicago, and Philadelphia, preparing an audience on Broadway for its arrival there.
Lloyd Richards, who directed the play, remembered standing in the ticket lobby of the theater. An African-American woman arrived to buy a ticket and he asked her, “What inspires you to see this production?” She replied, “Well, it was Sidney Poitier. He’s in this.”
“Well, you can see Sidney Poitier on screen for a fraction of the price,” replied Lloyd Richards. Her response was “I’ve heard about this play, and I’ve heard it concerns me.”
That quote, “I’ve heard it concerns me,” is a testament to the power of theater critics to get the word out about why theater matters for people.
